Best Pizza in Newington, CT
From NY-style slices to wood-fired pies — Milford delivers.
Newington's pizza scene reflects its character as a well-established suburban community where tried-and-true neighborhood joints serve as gathering spots along the Berlin Turnpike corridor and beyond. Whether you're craving thin crust, Neapolitan style, or classic Connecticut apizza, local pizzerias here have earned their reputation through consistent quality and genuine connections with residents from Cedarcrest to Mill Pond Park. These aren't trendy newcomers—they're the dependable spots where families celebrate and neighbors meet, making them central to Newington's community fabric.
Showing 8 top pizza places in Newington, CT
Phoenix Pizzeria holds a 4.8-star rating from 192 reviews — a strong signal for a pizza building its presence in Newington. Closed Monday. Call ahead to confirm availability.
Still under the radar but hard to ignore — Mama’s Pizzeria carries a 4.8-star rating from its first customers in Newington. Closed Monday. Visit their site for pricing and appointments.
Elm Hill Pizza has logged 543 reviews and held a 4.7-star rating, making it one of Newington's most established pizza. Check their website for hours and booking.
Bella Gourmet Pizzeria has built a solid following in Newington — 4.7 stars from 386 verified customers. Closed Monday. Call ahead to confirm availability.
With 919 reviews and a 4.6-star rating, Yannis Pizza Restaurant has become a reliable go-to for Newington residents. Visit their site for pricing and appointments.
Joey Garlic's Newington has logged 3175 reviews and held a 4.5-star rating, making it one of Newington's most established pizza. Check their website for hours and booking.
297 reviews and a steady 4.5-star average: Newington Pizza Restaurant has earned its standing among Newington pizza. Call ahead to confirm availability.
Own a pizza place in Newington?
Get featured on CT Finest and put your restaurant in front of hungry locals searching right now.
Get Listed →